(If you’ve already seen the movie, you may want to scroll down to the spoiler zone.)
A Serious Man is the Coen brothers’ (Fargo, No Country For Old Men, The Big Lebowski) latest film, and it’s a lot of fun. It is a Jewish parable of sorts, with two Jewish parables contained within. It’s the story of Larry Gopnik in a Minneapolis suburb in what is most likely 1970 (there are clues). He teaches Heisenberg’s uncertaintly principle as his day job, and lives it at home.
“But I didn’t do anything,” he insists when the Columbia Record Company continues to ship and bill him a record every month. And that’s the story of his life. His marriage, his kids, his work life teeter on the verge of disaster.
But he didn’t do anything.
This is the kind of story I can imagine my grandmother telling me– without all the naughty bits, of course. But my grandmother’s version would have a punchline, or a pat ending. It would leave me with a lot of questions, but would at least leave me with one great takeaway line, a moral, some truthiness that I could live by or live with.
But the Coens don’t leave you with anything but questions. Maybe this is the difference between a Jewish parable and a Hindu one? I don’t know, I’m a goy.
This movie did make me think about two things about movies in general:
- How soon after watching a movie should you be able to comfortably answer the question “What did you think”?
- How much of that answer, if answered right away, depends on the ending?
With this movie, it took me a day or two and I’m still not sure I can honestly tell you what I think about the movie. I don’t know if it’s a 4-star or a 5-star movie. And the ending made it unsatisfying at the time– I walked out expecting at least one more scene– but that ending is what might push it from 4-star material to 5-star. It is a fantastic gamble.
Todd McCarthy in Variety said, “This is the kind of picture you get to make after you’ve won an Oscar.” I’m not sure that’s true. The Coens have been making movies like this before the academy paid them notice, but he may have a point about the cast. Before the Oscar, they would have needed a few big names in there– if only indie big names, like Coen favorites John Turturro or John Goodman or Steve Buscemi.
SPOILER ZONE
If you haven’t seen the movie, turn back now, for here there be dragons. Continue reading →
You must be logged in to post a comment.